Settling Debate Between Liquid And Bar Soap

Settling Debate Between Liquid And Bar Soap

Bar Soap vs Liquid Soap: Which Wins?

Keeping your vacation rental stocked with all the necessary amenities guests love when they travel is an effective way to positively impact their trip and earn raving reviews. 

When it comes to providing them the essentials, the little things are what will ultimately enhance their experience, including determining the winner of: 

Bar soap vs liquid soap

Which do guests prefer?

Nearly 62 percent of guests expect their hosts to have soap readily available, according to a Modern Innkeeper survey, so let us identify the pros and cons to help decide which one you should impart on your guests!


Bar Soap Pros and Cons


Bar soap not only benefits your guests, but you and the planet, as well.


Saves Money

Your money goes further when you choose bar soap because it is generally more affordable and lasts longer.



Since each bar of soap requires less packaging, that means manufacturers consume less energy and resources to make it, which lessens the burden on our planet. 

Its packaging, usually paper or cardboard, is easier to recycle, too.



A common theory is bacteria stays on bar soap and transfers from one person to another. This is false. Bar soap acts as a proficient preventative measure from spreading diseases and keeps people healthy.


Does Not Trigger Reactions

Most bar soaps have glycerin, which is a carbohydrate that avoids provoking any dermatological-related conditions. 

You do not want a guest’s skin condition to flare up on vacation!



There is not much, but bar soap does come with some baggage.



Since a bar soap’s pH level is nearly double skin’s pH level, bar soap has a tendency to dehydrate it.



Bar soap is not in a bottle; therefore, it can look messy on a soap dish, taking on an unappealing mushy and slimy texture.


Liquid Soap Pros and Cons


Liquid soap does have some perks bar soap does not.



Liquid soap coming in a bottle makes it extremely user-friendly. All guests have to do is press down on the dispenser and wall-ah! Some soap lands in their hands.


Keeps Skin Moisturized

With a lower pH level than bar soap, guests will not have to deal with dry hands during their stay. It is more suited for people whose skin is on the sensitive side.



Liquid soap has multiple factors working against it.



Unlike the competition, liquid soap is costly. 

Requiring a bottle and dispenser, manufacturers use more materials, which you end up paying for when you buy it.


Harms the Environment

The aforementioned materials do not only cost more, but they also damage the environment.

The plastic container and dispensing device take up a significant amount of space in landfills, and the material they are made out of is more difficult to recycle than what goes into packaging bar soap.


Limited Options

If you want to bestow your guests a fragrance-free or handmade soap, you will have trouble finding a liquid soap that suffices.



The dispenser increases the chances of guests overusing liquid soap, which will require you to buy more sooner than you would if you supplied bar soap. 

Buying more of the pricier option is not ideal!


Our Winner is...

Both have notable attributes, and both have their downfalls. At the end of the day, you are running a business that you hope looks out for the welfare of your guests, our planet and yourself.

With that being said, we are crowning bar soap as our winner!

Take a look at all of these bar soap options you can provide your guests.